cast
-
Tamara Lynn Chambers
Dolores
-
Doug Walker
Nostalgia Critic
-
Malcolm Ray
Contestant #1
- Brett Bonynge Contestant #2
- Robbie Allen Bob
- Alyssa Jackson Barbara
- Paul Rohan Ben
- Jimmy Melf Reilly
- Harry Locke IV Julio
- Jim Jarosz Rolly the Fox/Practitioner
- Heather Reusz Atlantis Somerset
- Nick La Banca Nautical Nineties Narrator
- Justin Hoffman "Spin My Helm" Singer
- McKane Searle "Spin My Helm" Bassist
- James Banasiak "Spin My Helm" Drummer
- Alexis Banasiak Waving Woman 1
- Mooog Waving Woman 2
- Rob Scallon Waving Man
- Catheryn Kuhar Sailor Girl
- Danny Grenchik "Shark Weak" Singer
- Trevor Casterline "Poop Deck Peck" Harmony 1
- Tom Reusz "Poop Deck Peck" Harmony 2
- Aiyanna Wade Wife
- Steve Davis Husband
- Joe Banasiak Old Man
- Jim Banasiak Skeleton