cast
-
Tina Fey
Portia Nathan
-
Ann Harada
Mrs. Lafont
-
Ben Levin
Junior Lafont
-
Dan Levy
James
- Maggie Keenan-Bolger Girl on Tour
-
Gloria Reuben
Corinne
-
Paul Rudd
John Pressman
-
Wallace Shawn
Clarence
-
Elaine Kussack
Abby
-
Christopher Evan Welch
Brandt
- Michael Genadry Ben
- Juliet Brett Praying Applicant
-
John Brodsky
Smug Kid
- Camille Branton Gymnast
-
Sarita Choudhury
Rachael
-
Michael Sheen
Mark
-
Ken Barnett
Admissions Counselor
-
Nat Wolff
Jeremiah
- Travis Bratten Quest Student
-
Tanisha Long
Quest Student
-
Nadia Alexander
Quest Student
- Karen Pham Quest Student
- Travaris Spears Nelson
-
Lily Tomlin
Susannah
-
Rob Campbell
Richard
-
Sonya Walger
Helen
-
Olek Krupa
Polokov
-
Roby Sobieski
Makeout Guy
-
Lauren Schaffel
Student at Party
-
Brian Charles Johnson
Student at Party
-
Lipica Shah
Student at Party
-
Jarod Einsohn
Keg Guy
- Caliaf St. Aubyn Keg Guy's Friend
- Zita Geoffroy Tour Group Mom
-
Laura Jordan
Woman
-
Zachary Unger
Jeremiah - 8 Years Old
-
Lisa Emery
Mrs. Pressman
- Mihran Slougian Jeremiah's Dad
- Lynne Taylor Jeremiah's Mom
-
Brian d'Arcy James
Christopher Flynn
-
Leigha Hancock
Yulia Karasov
- Sarah Quinn Young Mother
- Jason Blaj Supermarket Kid
- David Simins A Capella Singer
- Brad Wilson A Capella Singer
- Ryan McCarty A Capella Singer
- Krishna Choudhary A Capella Singer
- Ricky Jones A Capella Singer
- Thomas Merckens A Capella Singer
- Alan Robert Southworth A Capella Singer
- Chris Bronwell A Capella Singer
- Chris Palermo A Capella Singer
- Anthony Capers Jeremiah's Buddy
- Julia Faye Fisher Agency Receptionist
-
Gameela Wright
Woman in Adoption Agency
- James P. Anderson Baxter Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)
-
Tina Benko
Andrea (uncredited)
- Matthew Broadley Twin Brother (uncredited)
-
Vanessa Carter
Quest Student (uncredited)
- Alix Cross Quest Student (uncredited)
-
Jonathon Culver
Quest Student (uncredited)
-
Giullian Yao Gioiello
Princeton Applicant (uncredited)
- Brandon Lee Harris Office Assistant (uncredited)
-
Alice Litvak
Twin Sister (uncredited)
- Nicole Maggio Lacrosse Girl (uncredited)
-
Alexis Molnar
Princeton College Applicant (uncredited)
- Meaghan Monaghan Student (uncredited)
- Rachel Moss Lacrosse Player (uncredited)
- Ismaelpeter Casillas Nelson Cow Milking Expert (uncredited)
-
Edward Sass III
Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)
- Danielle Senk Lacrosse Player (uncredited)
- Natasha Tax Prep School Girl (uncredited)
- Barbara Vincent Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)
-
Joshua Hinck
Sebastian