cast
-
Kimberly Williams-Paisley
Ida Graber
-
Tammy Blanchard
Amy Roberts
-
Fay Masterson
Jill Green
-
Madison Mason
Levi Brennaman
-
Gary Graham
Henry Taskey
-
Darcy Rose Byrnes
Rebecca Knepp
-
Karley Scott Collins
Katie Graber
-
Eugene Byrd
Danny
-
Bruce Nozick
Leonard
-
Amy Sloan
Rachel Knepp
-
John Churchill
Charlie Roberts
-
Madison Davenport
Mary Beth Graber
-
Matt Letscher
Gideon Graber
-
Eric Nenninger
State Trooper
-
Willow Geer
Judith
-
Christopher Curry
Minister
-
Kate Fuglei
Shelly
-
Jim Metzler
Sheriff
-
Bob Rumnock
Reporter
-
Emilee Wallace
Teacher Ruth
-
Jessica Dickey
Melinda
- Chloe Madison Sarah Knepp
-
Taylor Ann Thompson
Hannah
-
Trevor Thompson
Jacob
-
David Mazouz
Andy Roberts
-
Dale Wade Davis
Rachel's Husband
-
Joel Schmidt
Melinda's Husband
- David Curtis Amish Elder
-
Sammy Jack
Knepp Boy #1
- Gabriel Welch Knepp Boy #2
- Elijah Tadros Ryan Roberts
-
Caleb Babcock
Schoolboy (uncredited)
-
Daphne Blunt
Lilly (uncredited)
- Isabella Interian Lydia (uncredited)
- Marcus Shultz Knepp Teenager (uncredited)
- Johnny Wilson Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)