cast
-
Kyle Mooney
James Pope
-
Mark Hamill
Ted Mitchum
-
Jorge Lendeborg Jr.
Spencer
-
Matt Walsh
Greg Pope
-
Michaela Watkins
Louise Pope
-
Ryan Simpkins
Aubrey Pope
-
Greg Kinnear
Detective Vogel
-
Alexa Demie
Meredith
-
Jane Adams
April Mitchum
-
Claire Danes
Emily
-
Beck Bennett
Detective Bander
- Chance Crimin Logan
-
Andy Samberg
Eric
-
Kate Lyn Sheil
Arielle Smiles
- James Anthony Green Police Officer
- Kim Fischer Female Reporter
- Kelly Chapman News Anchor
-
Nick Rutherford
Brigsby Bear fan
- Reagan Pineda Reality Talking Head
- Kiera Milan Hendricks Young Smiles Sisters
-
Tim Heidecker
Coach Brad
- Rex Morgan Gordo
- Ellery Davidson Hannah Slice
- Christopher Sullivan FBI Agent
- Joseph Paul Branca Space Alien
-
Nikolas Mikkelsen
Theatre Patron
- Matthew P. Watts Prison Guard
- Ashlyn Brooke Anderson Wizzle Prince (uncredited)
-
Yvonne D Bennett
Party Guest (uncredited)
-
Kami Christiansen
Nurse (uncredited)
- Paul Nathan Cuthbert Prison Visitor (uncredited)
-
Teresa Duran-Norvick
Premiere Audience (uncredited)
-
Gerry Garcia
(uncredited)
- Angella Joy Reporter (uncredited)
-
Marilyn Miller
Court Reporter (uncredited)
-
Chris Provost
Prison Guard (uncredited)
- Seth Williams Cameraman (uncredited)
-
Julio Torres
Man Getting Haircut (uncredited)