cast
-
Billy Eichner
Bobby
-
Luke Macfarlane
Aaron
-
Guy Branum
Henry
-
Miss Lawrence
Wanda
-
Ts Madison
Angela
-
Dot-Marie Jones
Cherry
-
Jim Rash
Robert
-
Eve Lindley
Tamara
-
Monica Raymund
Tina
-
Guillermo Díaz
Edgar
-
Jai Rodriguez
Jason
-
Amanda Bearse
Anne
-
Debra Messing
Debra Messing
-
Peter Y. Kim
Peter
-
Justin Covington
Paul
-
Symone
Marty
-
Ryan Faucett
Josh
-
Becca Blackwell
Lucas
-
D'Lo
Tom
-
Harvey Fierstein
Louis
-
Bowen Yang
Lawrence Grape
- Dahlia Rodriguez Hannah
-
Derrick Delgado
Brian
-
George Dvorsky
Bruce
-
Jamyl Dobson
Joel
-
Brock Ciarlelli
Steve
-
Kenan Thompson
James Baldwin
-
Amy Schumer
Eleanor Roosevelt
-
Jillian Gottlieb
Samantha
-
Rick Crom
Grape's Neighbor
-
Everett Quinton
Melvin Funk
- Thomas Vorsteg Polyamorous Man
-
Julia Scotti
Straight Older Woman
- Feliziano Flores Rowdy Bear
- Allison Reese Aaron's Assistant
- Gara Lonning Receptionist
-
Nanie Méndez
Party Guest
- Eileen Noonan Party Guest
- Courtney Chu Teenage Girl
- Ryan Daly Grindr Guy
- Brayden Morgan Judgey Boy
-
William Popp
Pride Awards Football Player
-
Aidan Wharton
Football Player
- Jovan E'Sean Football Player
- Joey Taranto Singing Waiter
- Courtney Bassett Singing Waiter
- Joshua L.K. Patterson Singing Waiter
-
Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth
- Edythe Jason Paul's Grandma
- Lorenzo Scott Paul's Grandpa
- Keith Milkie Baseball Player
-
Alex Ringler
Baseball Player's Man
- Cedric Leiba, Jr. Harness Guy
- Clayton Paterson Hot Santa
- Legendary Monster Babylon Vogueing Man
- Doug Trapp Movie Exec
- Jesús Martínez Jr. Drag Queen
- Daren J. Fleming Drag Queen
-
Shannon O'Neill
Paula
-
Matthew Wilkas
Handsome Grindr Guy
- Charles J. Roby Wealthy Benefactor
-
Ben Stiller
Ben Stiller (uncredited)
-
Seth Meyers
Harvey Milk (uncredited)
-
Anthony DeVito
Straight Liberal Dad (uncredited)
- Joanne Lamstein Straight Liberal Mom (uncredited)