cast
- Matthew Fifer Ben
- Sheldon D. Brown Sam
- Sandra Bauleo Debbie
- Jazmin Grace Grimaldi Amber
-
Cobie Smulders
Sophie
-
Scott Adsit
Dr. Dragone
-
Michael Potts
Francis
-
David Burtka
Bo
-
Jo Firestone
Tracy
-
Jason Greene
Theresa
- Beau Curran Young Ben
-
Bowen Yang
Hudson
-
Clara McGregor
Riley
- Kevin William Reed Mike
- Ahmad Maksoud Mahmoud
-
Rain Dove Dubilewski
Josh
-
Tucker Des Lauriers
Justin
- Jace Moody Ray
-
Kian Talan
Keith
-
Alexandra Curran
Shay
- Rad Hourdakis Subway Guy
- Taka Kita Smoker
- Gil Rodriguez Gene
- Jessica Smith Steph
- Jillian Avery Chelsea
- John Onieal Sebastian
-
Ian Mellencamp
Jackson
-
Ayo Edebiri
Nikki
- Michelle Conti Sarah
-
Tanner Cohen
Seth (uncredited)
- Ashley Haas Jess (uncredited)
-
Anthony Oberbeck
Josh (uncredited)
-
Sarah Pribis
Jordan (uncredited)
-
Matt Rogers
Phillip (uncredited)
-
Simone Wasserman
Jill (uncredited)
- Jude Dry Charlie