cast
-
Joshua Zeman
Himself
-
Barbara Brancaccio
Herself
- Bill Ellis Himself - Professor of Folklore, Penn State
- Dorothy D'Eletto Herself - Archivist & Researcher
-
Geraldo Rivera
Himself - Reporter (archive footage)
- Karen Schweiger Herself - Jennifer Schweiger's Mother
- David Navarro Himself - Former Newscaster
- Donna Cutugno Herself - Founder, Friends of Jennifer
- Ralph Aquino Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD
- Bobby Jensen Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD
- Ernie Anastos Himself - Reporter (archive footage)
- Andre Rand Himself - Suspect
- Jim Callaghan Himself - Former Editor, Staten Island Eagle
- Jim Dolan Himself - Reporter (archive footage)
- Theresa Doyle Herself - Searcher for Jennifer
- Ed Armstrong Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother
- Sean Hughes Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother (archive footage)
- Peter Hughes Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Father
- Holly Cederholm Herself - Holly Ann Hughes's Mother
- Ken Schweiger Himself - Jennifer Schweiger's Father
- John O'Brien Himself - Reporter, Staten Island Advance
- Duane Felton Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand
- Larry Simon Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand
- William L. Murphy Himself - Staten Island District Attorney
- Trina Cutugno Herself - Donna's Daughter
- Devin Cutugno Himself - Donna's Son
- Jimmy Rassias Himself - Former Clerk, Port Richmond Deli
- Kristine Gosling Herself - Det. Sgt. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD
- Luis Rivera Himself - Retired Canine Officer, NYPD
- Frank Saez Himself - Ret. Det. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD
- Jack Whitford Himself - Stapleton Civilian Observation Patrol
- Thomas Jenkins Himself - Staten Island Resident
- Bob Graham Himself - Acquaintance of Rand
- Frances Auriti Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer
- Tracy Begley Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer
- Glenn Chapman Himself - Former Reporter, Staten Island Advance
- Leonard D'Alessandro Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD
- Martha Hinton Herself - Witness
- Frank Marchionne Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD
- Tanya Goodson Herself - Witness
- Rita Dimartino Herself - Aunt of Alice Pereira
- Charles G. Muskett Sr. Himself - Former Minister
- Steve Bogen Himself
- Patricia Caridad Herself
- Robert Caruso Himself
- Greg Cusick Himself
- Charlie Cutugno Himself
- Daniel M. Donovan Jr. Himself - District Attorney for Richmond County
- Marla Dziergowski Herself
- Robert Foster Himself
- Melissa Grace Herself
- Judah Lazarus Himself
- Bruce Meyersen Himself
- Thomas Micol Himself - Staten Island Resident
- Carolyn Muskett Herself
- Marie Piazza Herself
- Lorraine Shanley Herself
- Brett Straniere Himself