cast
-
Paul Rudd
Paul
-
Steve Coogan
Erasmus
-
Jack Gore
Bill
-
Alison Pill
Melissa
-
Jake McDorman
Beau
-
Jesse Luken
Director
-
Lora Martinez-Cunningham
Ms. Garcia
-
Sarah Minnich
Crack Head Lady
-
Stafford Douglas
Caterer
-
Jacob Browne
Judge Pierce
-
Frances Lee McCain
Doris
- Josey Smith Whitney
-
Kate Walsh
Kate
-
Jenny Gabrielle
Betty
-
Monique Candelaria
Officer Guttierez
- Alexandra Guarnaschelli Alex Guarnaschelli
-
Courtney Cunningham
Paramedic
-
Drew Droege
Drew
-
Marie Wagenman
Little Girl
-
Cassandra Rochelle Fetters
Party Goer
-
Evan Bittencourt
Tino
- Rodrigo Tactaquin Biker
-
Mark Rowe
Suburban Dad
- Eric Womack Officer Forrest
-
Richard Beal
Church Member
-
Jordyn Aurora Aquino
Leticia
-
Clint Obenchain
Waiter
-
J. Nathan Simmons
Wise Man #1
- Alexander Daniel Pimentel Suburban Dad's Friend
-
Kristin K. Berg
Taco Bell Manager
- Emma Armstrong Checkout Girl
- Stephen Conn Christmas Reveler / Church decorator / Lighting tech
- Michael E. Stogner Drunk Santa (uncredited)
- Amanda Quintana-Bowles Christmas Reveler
- Alison Grainger Taco Bell Patron
- Rick Tadra Maddy
- Patrick V. Murphy Party goer
- Ian Morris Bill's Friend
- Ronnie Gomez Wise Man #3
- Jeremiah Fresquez Student #1
- Viola Valdez Parishioner
- Justin Lotz Wise Man #2
- Mason Howell Bills Friend
-
Sheila Eden
Tango Wife (uncredited)
-
Sylvie Grontis Hagan
Teacher (uncredited)
- Amy Emily Stack Inmate Visitor (uncredited)