cast
-
Mel Gibson
Gene Carruthers
-
Mason Thames
Noah Reed
-
Julian Lerner
Eugene Wexler
-
Abby James Witherspoon
Sammy Devers
-
Noah Cottrell
Ben Driskel
-
Nora Zehetner
Abby Reed
-
Lorraine Bracco
Miss Halverson
-
Emma Fasano
Lilly Reed
-
Spencer Fitzgerald
Ronnie Harlow
-
Patrick Renna
Umpire
-
Ashley Rae Riddick
Witch
-
Gavin Bedell
Kevin Lampkey
-
Gary Weeks
Chief Hartley
-
Bobbi Baker
Hannah Driskel
-
Kelly Collins Lintz
Deb Harlow
-
Nico Tirozzi
Little Boy / Carruthers' Son
-
Lilah Pate
Ellie Evans
-
Kevin James
Edgar Palmer
-
Barbara Goodson
The Witch (voice)
- Abrielle Josephine Cincotti Emily
- Nick Benas Baseball Fan (uncredited)
- Parker E. Chick Town Kid (uncredited)
- Sara Elizabeth Ezzell Diner Patron / Pedestrian (uncredited)
-
Robert Fortunato
Police Officer (uncredited)
- Keeley Kollmann Mom with Kids (uncredited)
- Samantha Miro Jogger (uncredited)
-
Art Newkirk
Dad in Theater (uncredited)
- Logan Newkirk Book Signing Kid (uncredited)
- Violet Berlus Skip-It Girl
- Lara Fontes Lilly (voice)
- Hannah Michelle Pedestrian
- Mary Clare Mitchell Diner Patron
- Lucretia Newkirk Tourist
-
David Pascua
Police Officer
- Veronica Russell Baseball Spectator
- Stacey Stewart Carruthers' Wife
- James Richard Wemmitt Camera Man