cast
- Rick Sparks Peter Pan
- Melany Bell Wendy Darling
-
Wil Wheaton
John Darling
- Marcus Reynaga Michael Darling
-
David Jahn
George Darling
- Deborah Quayle Mary Darling
-
Kari Wahlgren
Tinker Bell
-
Joey
Nana
- Stephanie Kirchen Liza
- Gary Kelley James Hook
-
Scott Mechlowicz
Sam "Smee" Smiegel
- Ryan Patrick Kelly Tootles
- Ian Mantha Slightly
- Eli Swanson Curly
- Zach Cole Nibs
- Tyler Kremer Twin
- Nathan Towry Twin
- Ray Garcia Tiger Lily
-
Kevin Christy
Crocodile
- Karim Imam Cecco
- Gilberto Aguilera Starkey
-
Richard John Walters
Bill Jukes
- Steven Reiswig Cookson
- Jake Winsryg Tinker Bell's Kid
- Reed Prescott Boyfriend
- Craig Jackman Park Announcer
- Saadia Billman Mermaid
- Jill Kocalis Mermaid
-
Elena Fabri
Mermaid
- Karen Blake Challman Indian
-
Monica Louwerens
Indian
- Al Bee Indian
- Red Savage Indian
- Roman Vasquez Indian
- Yayoi Ito Indian