cast
- Kevin Arnold Perry 'Pears' Matthews
- Olivia Schaperjohn Tiffany
- Jillian Weinzapfel Jessica Archer
- Jeremy Brailsford Hollis Archer
- Leo Kempf Sly
- Joe Gilpatrick Ritchie
- Jakob Bilinski Derek DeGarmo
- Emily Durchholz Sarah Hightower
- Kevin Roach Eddie Hightower
- Alice Shen Simone
- Jeffrey Dumond Frank Guthridge
- Shahzaib Raza PhoneGuy
- LilyBea Ireland Heartbreaker
- Takeyah Barnhill Angela Guthridge
- Bruce Womback Grandpa Tom
-
Deborah Lee Hall
Parking-Lot Karen
- Alyssa Rhoads Yoga Instructor
- Lily McCurdy Tiffany's Friend #1
- Gennie Adams Tiffany's Friend #2
- Crystal Mullen Tiffany's Friend #3
- Nathan Veazey Mr. Meyers
- Kurt McWilliams Mr. Meyer's Boyfriend
- Chelsea Sowder Comic Book Store Patron
- Marci McCurdy Karen's Grandbaby
- Lincoln McCurdy Karen's Grandbaby