cast
-
Danielle Panabaker
Katie Lapp
-
Sherry Stringfield
Laura Mayfield-Bennett
- Sarah Maine Jessica
- Willie Stratford Theodore
- Jason Loughlin Benjamin Lapp
-
Sandra Elise Williams
Rebecca Lapp
-
Bill Oberst Jr.
Samuel Lapp
- Wyatt Lanier Jacob Beiler
-
Burgess Jenkins
Bishop John Beiler
- Dalton Parrish Hickory John Beiler
- David Topp Daniel Fisher
-
Richard Fullerton
Ephram Yoder
-
Nancy Saunders
Ella Mae Zook
-
Rachel St. Gelais
Benjamin's Daughter
-
Jana Allen
Amanda
- Sarah E. Chambers Mary Stoltzfus
- Jimmy Hager Preacher Yoder
- David Forrester Amish Elder
-
Robert C. Treveiler
Surgeon
- Stephen West-Rogers Trauma Nurse
- Lee Freeman Nurse Rosie
-
Alexa Yeames
Young Laura
- Tim Holt Dylan Bennett
- Michele Lee Store Clerk
-
Lindsey Moser
Nurse (uncredited)
- Scott Helm Amish Man
- Jacob Allen Young Amish Bachelor (Uncredited)
- Kirk Bass Young Samuel (Uncredited)
- Leanne Bernard Bus Patron (Uncredited)
- Randy Bernard Bus Patron (Uncredited)
- Hailey Best Self / Self - Nurse (Uncredited)
- Elijah Chester Amish Guy (Uncredited)
-
Darren W. Conrad
Amish Man (Uncredited)
- Lee Ryan Coston Amish Woman in Shop (Uncredited)
-
Christina Cupo
Bus Patron (Uncredited)
- Beth Gosnell Amish woman (Uncredited)
- Beth Hawkes Wedding Guest (Uncredited)
- Tessa Taylor Herrick Amish Woman in Cab (Uncredited)
- Nick Karner Amish Man at General Store (Uncredited)
- Dan A.R. Kelly Amish Man (Uncredited)
- Jerry Keys Amish Elder (Uncredited)
- Janine Lorraine Amish Woman (Uncredited)
- Jason Mac Noah Beiler (Uncredited)
- Chris Manitius Young Boy (Uncredited)
- Shasta Mejia Hotel Guest (Uncredited)
- Melissa Milch Young Amish Woman (Uncredited)
- Addy Miller Amish Girl (Uncredited)
- David R. Moore Young Amish Man (Uncredited)
-
Gary Ray Moore
Amish Man (Uncredited)
- Tina Murphy Young Rebecca (Uncredited)
- David Dickson Reynolds Amish Elder (Uncredited)
-
Karen Wheeling Reynolds
Amish Woman (Uncredited)
- Chris Sprister Amish Man (Uncredited)
- Tara-Nicole Warner Amish Teenager (Uncredited)
- Brandi Alyssa Young Amish Woman (Uncredited)