cast
-
Paul Giamatti
Mike Flaherty
-
Amy Ryan
Jackie Flaherty
-
Bobby Cannavale
Terry Delfino
-
Jeffrey Tambor
Vigman
-
Burt Young
Leo Poplar
-
Melanie Lynskey
Cindy Timmons
-
Alex Shaffer
Kyle
-
Margo Martindale
Eleanor
-
David Thompson
Stemler
-
Nina Arianda
Shelly
- Mike Diliello Jimmy Reed
-
Marcia Haufrecht
Gina Flaherty
-
Sharon Wilkins
Judge Lee
-
Clare Foley
Abby
-
Penelope Kindred
Stella
-
Sophie Kindred
Stella
-
Tim Ransom
Stuart Thatcher
- Nicholas Somers BHS Coach
- Jacqueline Brogan Woman Jogging
-
Marceline Hugot
Woman Jogging
-
Edmund Ikeda
Frank
-
Joseph Tiboni
Steve Deluca / Principal
-
Pam Levine
Church Soloist
-
Darren Goldstein
Sheffield Coach
-
Dariusz M. Uczkowski
Zachary Lowenstein
- Earl Baker Jr. Staff Member
- Nicholas Lopez Anthony Pizzno
- Austin Ward Peter Molter
-
Emma Degerstedt
Miss Durrance (uncredited)
-
Joanna Theobalds
Gina (uncredited)
- Jill DeMonstoy Wrestling Mom (uncredited)
-
Tom McArdle
Wrestling Match Announcer (uncredited)
-
Cliff Moylan
Contractor (uncredited)