cast
-
Hank Azaria
Jim Brockmire
-
Tyrel Jackson Williams
Charles
-
Amanda Peet
Jules James
-
Hemky Madera
Pedro Uribe
-
Katie Finneran
Lucy Brockmire
-
Tawny Newsome
Gabby Taylor
-
J.K. Simmons
Matt "The Bat" Hardesty
-
Reina Hardesty
Beth
-
Paul Rae
Dale
-
Victoria Blade
Limòn / Debbie / Limòn
-
Richard Kind
Gus Barton
-
Ryan Lee
John Elton
-
Steve Coulter
Coach Pom Pom
-
Toby Huss
Johnny the Hat
-
Alex Phipps
Ryan Stanton
-
Adan Rocha
Danny Cruz
-
Daisuke Tsuji
Yoshi Takatsu
-
Molly Ephraim
Bartender
-
Utkarsh Ambudkar
Raj
-
David Walton
Gary
-
Dreama Walker
Whitney
-
Becky Ann Baker
Jean Brockmire Glasscock
-
Martha Plimpton
Shirley
-
Christine Woods
Maggie Nickols
-
Jay DeVon Johnson
Moderator
-
Joe Buck
Joe Buck
-
Ego Nwodim
Liz
-
Brian F. Durkin
Robbie Butler
-
Carrie Preston
Elle
-
Adriyan Rae
Yvonne
-
Phil Reeves
Art Newlie
-
Christian Robinson
Dave / Dave (uncredited)
-
Ron Clinton Smith
Freddie
-
Shane Donovan Lewis
BBQ Boy / Lil Pete
-
Michael Koske
Ticket Taker / Barons Fan / Concession Stand Worker
-
Tracey Bonner
Cassie
-
Travon Mcfarland
Two Hands
-
Mary Kraft
Sam / Chastity
-
Bob Costas
Bob Costas
-
Courtney Sauls
Gayle / Gabby's Partner
-
Charles Green
Norman Glasscock
-
Quinn Cooke
Denise
-
John Ales
New York Yankees Owner
- Dominic Cancelliere Lil' Diazepam
-
David Pressman
Orion
-
Andrew Hill Newman
Dr. Barrett
-
Angela Relucio
Floribeth's Aunt
-
Adelle Drahos
Podcast Superfan
-
Sean Goulding
Hungry Fan
-
Joshua Hoover
Fatty Bombalatty
- Thomas Hughes Smoking Fracker Player
- David Iwanicki Bombalatty Brother
- Glenn Walkup Butler 3rd Base Coach
- Sarah Eliza Argens Food Ciry Girl #2
- Perry Johnson Bar Patron
-
Lilly Roberson
Cindy
-
Keisuke Hoashi
Translator
- Ruben Bugayong Slap Boxing Friend
- Scot Reddy Butler Fan
- Haji Abdullah Large Man
-
John Atwood
Bill Douglas
-
Aina Dumlao
Diwata Cruz
-
Matt Mercurio
Wacky Auctioneer
-
Allie McCulloch
Female Brock-Head
-
Vince Pisani
Male Brock-Head
-
Ira Glass
Ira Glass
- Jeremy Madden Annoying Selfie Fan
- Dan McDonough Hipster
-
Ron Perkins
Abortion Doctor
-
Heather Ayers
Diana
-
Ross Marquand
Brockmire's Father
-
Rich Eisen
Rich Eisen
-
Brian Kenny
Brian Kenny
-
Jonah Keri
Jonah Keri
-
Tim Kurkjian
Tim Kurkjian
-
Kenny Mayne
Kenny Mayne
-
Dan Patrick
Dan Patrick
- Ethan Daniels Bat Boy Calhoun
- Marc Demeter Fracker Fan
- Destiny Lopez Pub Girl
-
Al Mitchell
Umpire
-
Melanie Loren
Chantal
-
Todd Davis
Podcast Superfan
- Avery E. King Festival Fan
-
Kimrie Lewis
Bobbi
-
Clifton Powell
Charles Sr.
-
Adam Drescher
Stadium Manager
-
Paul Brian Johnson
Terry
- Elizabeth Youman Charlie
-
Zamani Wilder
Charlynn Richmond
-
Hakim Callender
Damon
-
Ted Huckabee
Leland
- Todd Davis Spectator
-
Benjamin Weaver
Spectator
-
Lindsay Ayliffe
Minister
-
Jef Holbrook
Nephew Jim
- Jeff K. Lester Selfie Guy
- Greg Puckett Funeral Attendant
-
Valerie Jane Parker
Groupie
- Duran Butler Waiter
- Jamie Dion Garrett
-
Sarah Blackman
Nicole
-
Jared Simon
Doctor #1
-
Selena Anduze
Doctor #2
-
Sydney Wease
Mascot
- Anthony B. Harris Medical Intern
-
Wesley Kuykendoll
Rick
-
Joe Knezevich
Greg
- Matt Myers Patient
-
Drew Starkey
Brad Christie
- Jimi Kocina Dale
- Donald Ray Arnold Spectator
- Brittany Kelly Waitress
- John Scarvey Oakland Fan
-
Kodai Yamaguchi
Baseball Fan
-
George Brett
George Brett
-
Lauren Halperin
Receptionist
-
Frank Brennan
Mr. Benjamin
- Ryan Vo Holy Shit Guy
- Michael D'Elia Waiter
- Bissette Williams Gamer Girl
-
Dan Castellaneta
Duke Yipkowski (voice)
-
Linda Lavin
Lorraine
- Justin Miles
- Thomas DuPont
-
Robert Tinsley
Oakland A's Baseball Player (uncredited)
- Michele Jang Dakota
- Ginger Curl Pat
- Jordan Iacovella Young Jim
-
Natalie Renee Long
Young Lucy
- Andrea Maiuro Doctor
- Travis James Newlie Fan #2
- Cole Nowacki Newlie Fan #1
- Holden Scott Jared
-
Suehyla El-Attar Young
Kansas City Royals Staff Member
- Aria Que Young Floribeth
- Matt Markopoulos Military Guard
- Vanessa Padla Manila Pedestrian
- Peg O'Keef Spry Grandma
-
Jonathon Pawlowski
Reporter
-
Benny Thrasher
Brad
- Jacob Wilhelmi Bad Grandson
-
David Sullivan
Rusty
-
Alana Cavanaugh
Young Jules
-
Rebecca Koon
Carol
-
Cliff Weissman
The Great Tomás
-
Michael Bunin
Leslie
-
Lynne Ashe
Human Resources Manager
-
J. LaRose
Chief Sango Whitehorse
-
Julian B Lin
Stadium Employee
-
Ruben Vidal
Colonizers #22
- Brigitte Bidet Dolly
- Kitana Goyena Teenage Beth
- Ilmer Osorio Cult Leader
-
Valerie Azlynn
Janet
-
Matt Levin
Man
- Jassey Kris Hilotin Eden
-
Kevin Patrick Murphy
Limòn Stranger
- Ashley Uecker Hall of Fame attendee
- Eric Wilkerson Hall of Fame VIP
-
Paul F. Tompkins
Harold K. Finnegan
-
Aaron Gillespie
Benny Rodriguez
-
Fray Forde
'Symphony' Pitchman
- Charity Hitchcock Lennox
-
Haroon Khan
Confused Teenager
-
Andrea Laing
Bernice
- Ivana J. Lewis Jasper
-
Mason Pike
Pedestrian
- Jack Marino Barfly
-
David Silverman
Dylan's Dad
