cast
-
Stanley Andrews
Old Ranger
-
Robert Taylor
Self - Host / Shanghai Kelly
-
Ronald Reagan
Self - Host / David Glasgow Farragut
-
Dale Robertson
Self - Host
- Melody McGowan Elvira Curry age 12 / Bennett's older daughter / Betsy Phinney / Young Ayoka / Young Isabella
-
DeForest Kelley
Clint Rogers / Martin / Shad Cullen / Elliott Webster
- Laton Riley Kirk Sr. James Arcane / DeCourcey / Dr Henry Cabell / Don Pedro
-
Tristram Coffin
Mayor / George Bennett / Major Henry
- Nancy Rennick Ann Alton / Margaret Lea / Ellie Hogue
-
John Alderson
John Tunstall (as John Anderson) / Hugh Glass
-
Don Megowan
Buck / Buff McCloud
-
Carl Reindel
Jack Desmond / Jim Bridger
-
Eleanor Berry
Ana Carter / Mrs. Stuart (as Eleanore Berry)
-
William Smith
Dan Turner / Marshall Hendry Brown
-
William Schallert
Dave Meiser / Ellis Higby
-
Paul Birch
Mike Walsh / Jim Davidson
-
Ken Mayer
Will Buck / Seth Bremen
-
Sid Haig
Thief / Farber
-
John Pickard
Emery / Sheriff Francis
-
Tom Lowell
Emmett Butler / Jim Kirby
-
Lomax Study
Henri Charpaud / Joe Goodman
- Bernard Szold Station Agent / Caldiwell
-
Ann Savage
Diamond Babe
-
Brad Johnson
Lewis Manly
-
Phyllis Coates
Virginia Arcane
-
Robert Blake
William Bonney - Billy the Kid
-
Lane Bradford
L. G. Murphy
-
Slim Pickens
Wall Kennedy
-
Richard Beymer
John Owens (as Dick Beymer)
-
Gregg Palmer
David Randall
-
Patrice Wymore
Fay Morgan
-
Robert Colbert
Ray Ritter
-
Soon-Tek Oh
Matsunosuke Sakurai (as Soon-Taik Oh)
-
Sherry Jackson
Katherine Turner
-
Irene Tedrow
Mrs. Hemingway
-
Morgan Woodward
Fitzpatrick
-
Victor French
Louis Baptiste
-
John Hoyt
Crandel
-
Wayne Rogers
George Schmidtlein
-
Harry Lauter
Henry Schmidtlein
-
Michael Dante
Capt. Richard Rocha
-
Cesar Romero
Don Augustin Olvera
-
Anna Navarro
Delores Olvera
-
Ida Lupino
Pamela Mann
-
James T. Callahan
Private Riggs (as James Callahan)
-
James Coburn
Steve Barnes
-
Yvonne De Carlo
Dr. Clare Reed
-
John Vivyan
Ed Taylor
-
Robert Anderson
Sheriff
-
Dick Foran
Ferguson
-
Grace Lee Whitney
Verna
-
James Flavin
Perry
-
Joseph Ruskin
Jeb Daley
-
Hampton Fancher
Ned Murphy
-
Adrienne Hayes
Amy Murphy
-
Robert Culp
Thomas Burdue / James Stuart
-
John Zaremba
Judge Parsons
-
June Dayton
Virginia Farragut
- William Douglas Lt. Burnell
-
Mary Murphy
Marianne
-
Chanin Hale
Flora
-
Robert Bice
Capt. Longden
-
Robert Karnes
Brandon
-
Robert Pine
Sailor
-
Michael McHale
Harvey Pierce (as Mike McHale)
-
Don Grady
Calvin Hays
-
Arthur Space
Ben Hudson
-
Laurie Carroll
Sharon
-
Anna-Lisa
Huldah Swanson
-
Dub Taylor
Rupert
-
Guy Prescott
Barnaby Taylor
-
Patricia Donahue
Frances Trent
-
Jack Kenney
Contest Judge
-
Susan Brown
Nancy Cooper
-
Darren McGavin
Zacharias Gurney
- Barry Harvey Rev Endicott Peabody
-
Tol Avery
Mayor George Hubble
-
Emily Banks
Margaret Hubble
- Roy Engel Jonas Dunne
-
Luke Halpin
Sandy King
- Dan Sheridan Sheriff Bowman
- Joe Lo Presti Chappe
-
Jim Davis
Ezra Meeker
-
Patricia Smith
Eliza Jane Meeker
- Richard Schuyler Man
- Fred Krone White
-
John Parrish
Asa Bell Bennett
-
Louise Lorimer
Sarah Bennett
-
Guy Wilkerson
Enoch Fish
- Molly McGowan Martha Bennett
-
James Griffith
Aaron Winters
-
Donna Martell
Rosie Winters
-
Hank Patterson
Phi Jones
- Poppy del Vando Sunflower Jones
-
Allan Nixon
Jeff Stevens
- Rosa Turich Rosie's mother
- Richard Emory The Death Valley Kid
-
Bruce Edwards
Sheriff Jim Manning
- Jackson Halliday Wayne
-
Michael Jeffers
Townsman
- Jack Hardin Suds
-
Ann McCrea
Lucy
-
Walter McGrail
Charlie
-
Buddy Roosevelt
Townsman
-
Suzanne Ridgway
Townswoman
- Allen D. Sewall Townsman
- Jimmy Noel Townsman
- Tex Terry Stage Driver
- Tex Holden Shotgun Rider (uncredited)
-
Al Bain
Townsman (uncredited)
-
Frank O'Connor
Townsman (uncredited)