cast
-
Robert Levey II
Corey / Zack / Seth Wrinkles
-
Marian Murray
Angela Parsons Kreider (Alec's Mom) / Psychiatrist / Teri Knight (voice)
-
Griffin Wallace Henkel
Young Aaron Christopher Foust / Ron's friend
-
Kat Lindsay
Joylynn Martinez
- Andrew Spieker Brian
- Ian Zelbo Young Jamie
-
Alex Cerdeira
Teen Jamie
-
Molly Gazay
Kimberly
- Patricia Lawrence Grandmother
- Jack Malykin Police Officer
- Scott Manginelli Police Officer
- Lynn Marocola Police Officer (uncredited)
-
Ava Briglia
Young Lindsay
- Adeleen Rosner Teen Lindsay
- Tim Rerucha Eric Wrinkles
- Marta Kotzian Debbie Wrinkles
- Marian Edmiston Aunt Jenny
- Shannon Krowicki Aunt Natalie
- Hannah Brahney Young Melissa
- Castor Feinberg Middle Melissa
- Brittany Shaffer Teen Melissa
- Jason Eric Ross Keith Jesperson
-
Graceann Dorse
Rose Jesperson
- Robert James Hickey Grandfather
-
Dominic DiGravio
Alec Kreider
-
Mason Cufari
Roberta's son
-
Wesley Holloway
Jason
-
Jon Martens
Boy
-
Joey Gregoire
Young Michael
-
Charlotte Fountain-Jardim
Sister
-
Ethan Mathias
Young Daniel
- Kent R. Williams Roy
-
Karen Kuzma
Self - Sister
- Patricia Alsobrook Self (archive footage)
- Robyn Babina Mom
- Isabelle Grace Ballard Kim Ghelkins
- Dennis Bellamy Self (archive footage)
-
Josh Bernard-Kriegl
Walter Neeley
- Doreen Dempsey Self (archive footage)
- Robin Dempsey Self - Doreen's Infant Daughter (archive footage)
- Shirley Gaskins Self - Donald 'Pee Wee' Gaskins' Daughter
- Kim Ghelkins Self (archive footage)
-
Travis Kerr
Donald Gaskins
- Janice Kirby Self (archive footage)
- Johnny Knight Self (archive footage)
- Colleen McGloin Mother-in-Law
-
Alex Schecter
Johnny Knight
-
David Schifter
Peewee Gaskins
- Deborah Tighe Suzanne Kipper
-
Keeley Karsten
Child Pam Sinclair
-
Steve Lichtenstein
Mr. Andrews
-
Sarah Ann Leahy
Patty
- Tyler Shore Sheriff's Deputy
-
Arabella Olivia Clark
Young Renee
-
Kailey Merida
Older Teenage Sister
-
Scott Watson
Bobby Long
- Donny Ness Young Eric Witte
-
Sophia Guarnaschelli
Young Sherry
-
Noah Feldman
Teen Brother #1
