cast
- Katie Stone Pamela Smart
- Sean Alan Stone Billy Flynn
-
Braden Balazik
Classmate / Teresa Stanley's Kid 1 / Paper Boy
- Cooper Justin Grisham Classmate / Sick Boy #3
- Casey Grisham Classmate / Boy on bicycle #2 (uncredited)
-
Ahmad Salah
Mohammed Bin Laden / Army Soldier
- David Burkhart Charles Manson
-
April Yanko
Karla Homolka
-
Jax Hintergardt
Shannon Schultz
- Michael Karash Young Dennis Rader
- István Mihály Hospital Kid
- Parker Niksich Young John Wayne Gacy
-
Major Dodge
John Gotti
-
Giovannie Cruz
Victoria Gotti
-
Major Dodge Jr.
John Gotti Jr.
- Ryan T. Johnson Paramedic
-
Joy Leigh
Temple Member
- Savannah Solsbery Teresa Stanley's Kid 2
- Jack Doke Young Vernon Howell
-
Jonathan Charles
Young Ted Kaczynski
-
Stephen Brodie
Roman Polanski
-
Randall Tyree Brooks II
Sean Schultz
-
Isak Tufic
Douglas Glenn Cyr
-
Stephen A. Elkins
Jimmy Breslin
-
Step Rowe
Pamela Wilkening
-
Kevin Saunders
Officer Shultz
-
Crew Wyard
Roger
- Aaron Uribe A.B Quintanilla
-
Jodi Arias
Self (archive footage)
-
Erin Robinson
Young Laurie