cast
-
Keegan-Michael Key
Josh Skinner
-
Cecily Strong
Melissa Gimble
-
Dove Cameron
Jenny Banks / Betsy McDonough
-
Alan Cumming
Mayor Aloysius Menlove / Dooley Blight
-
Kristin Chenoweth
Miss Codwell / Mildred Layton
-
Aaron Tveit
Topher / Danny Bailey
-
Jaime Camil
Doc Jorge Lopez / Sergeant Rivera
-
Ann Harada
Florence Menlove / Madam Frau
-
Ariana DeBose
Emma Tate / Emcee
- Daniel Bernardo Core Dancer
-
Amanda Cleghorn
Core Dancer
-
Julia Harnett
Core Dancer
- Gray Monczka Core Dancer
-
Serena Crouse
Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl Annie
- Ashley Brooke St. John Core Dancer
- Ericka Hunter Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl Molly
- Julio Fuentes Core Dancer
- Derek Piquette Core Dancer
- Warren Yang Core Dancer
- Marina Lazzaretto Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl
-
Amitai Marmorstein
Pete the Milkman / Skeet the Hot Dog Man / Skeet the Juror
-
Katrina Reynolds
Core Dancer / Court Observer / Backup Singer
-
Fred Armisen
Reverend Howard Layton
- Liam Quiring-Nkindi Carson
-
Alex Gullason
Alex / Young Woman #1
- Jessica Keeling Core Dancer
-
Tituss Burgess
Narrator
-
Michael Delleva
Michael
- Caitriona Murphy Core Dancer / Court Observer
-
Karin Konoval
Female Barfly / Female Barfly (voice)
-
Sarah Formosa
Core Dancer
- Shelley Stewart Hunt Core Dancer
-
Kevin McNulty
Farmer McDonough / Father Flanagan
-
Jane Krakowski
Bobby Flanagan / Countess Gabriele Von Blerkom
-
Darcey Johnson
Innkeeper Harvey / Reporter
-
Scott Patey
Larry the Fireman / Reporter
-
Patrick Page
Octavius Kratt
- Bijou Brattston Tootie McDonough / Orphan Dancer
- Marisa Gold Marisa
- Milana Wan Orphan / Orphan Dancer
- Kris Grzella Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer / Jail Dancer
-
Garfield Wilson
Henry the Iceman
- Jak Barradell Core Dancer
- Tristan Chad Ghostkeeper Core Dancer
- Jared Khalifa Core Dancer
-
Troy Mclaughlin
Core Dancer
- Matt Nethersole Core Dancer
- Sam Strasfeld Core Dancer
-
Isabel Birch
Little Orphan
- Kairo Ellis Orphan
-
Bianca Melchior
Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer / Kelly, Audition Dancer
- Shane Simpson Core Dancer / Jail Dancer / Tribal Dancer
-
Kyra Leroux
Carrie
- Astrid Trueman Nellie
-
Pedro Salvín
Old Doc Lopez
-
Sarah Hayward
Helen
-
Martin Short
Steve the Leprechaun / Oscar the Leprechaun
-
Michelle Rios
Mrs. Lopez
- Josh St. John Core Dancer
-
Andrew Kyrzyk
Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer
-
Alex Wong
Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer
-
Justine Gera
Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer / Cabaret Girl Elsie Vale
- Sharona D'Ornellas Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer / Cabaret Girl Pepper
- Katherine Gayle Core Dancer / Cabaret Girl / Tribal Dancer
- Viola Abley Freckle-Faced Girl
-
Nolen Dubuc
Buck-Toothed Boy
- Ridley Havok McLeod Wild Hair Boy
-
Peyton Amelia Feltham
Tap Dancer / Choir
- Anthony Juo Choir / Tap Dancer
- Ema Lake Choir / Tap Dancer
- Jenna Lamb Choir / Tap Dancer
- Alisa Lymar Choir / Tap Dancer
- Leah Park Choir / Tap Dancer
- Matias Wong Choir / Tap Dancer
-
Alex Barima
Freddy
- Cassandra Consiglio Nancy
-
Arielle Tuliao
Woman #3 / Barfly Singer
- Willow Rose Walker Young Melissa
-
Ella Wejr
Orphan Dancer / Dance Orphan #3
-
Peppermint
Madam Vina
-
Timothy Webber
Marv
- David Adams Corn Puddin' Cook
-
Jason Burkart
Buford Riggs
-
Stephanie Cho
Waitress
-
Thomas Wayne Hum
Husband Ted
- Levi McCachen Like Minded Guy
-
Iris Quinn
Joanna
-
Nikolai Witschl
Undertaker
-
Leana Yu
Birthing Woman Holly
-
Style Dayne
DJ
- Whitney Lykins Bridesmaid
-
Rryla McIntosh
Bride
-
Emma Pedersen
Young Woman #2
- Inca Scott Tap Dancer
-
Dolores Drake
Biddy #1
-
Eileen Barrett
Biddy #2
- Immanuel Chibota Newsie
-
Felice Kakaletris
Little Girl
-
Yvette Lu
Fertility Doctor
-
Jessica Vosk
Little Girl's Mother
-
Sandy Robson
Angry Dad
-
Patti Allan
Mrs. Silwinski
- Joshua Harding Josh's Patient
-
Lee Shan Gibson
Cop
- Holly Arthur Josh's Patient
- Phillip Joseph Steward Josh's Patient
-
Matt Afonso
Robber Prisoner
-
Justin Stone
Conrad Prisoner
-
Steeven K.
Jazz Musician
-
Micaela Nyland
Priscilla, Audition Dancer
- Mark Logtenberg Killer Prisoner
-
Michael Q. Adams
Advisor
-
David Beairsto
Advisor
-
Gerry South
Judge
- Jennie Ford Court Stenographer
-
Ellexis Wejr
Orphan Dancer
-
Alice Comer
Tiny Tap Dancer
- Aletheia Berry Orphan Dancer
- Jacob Ian Dalzell Orphan Dancer
- Haven Gin Orphan Dancer
- Joy Lho Orphan Dancer
- Ayla McMillan Orphan Dancer
- Noah Park Orphan Dancer
- Lincoln Russo Orphan Dancer
- Anya-Shae Johnson Orphan Dancer
- Cole Sivertson Orphan Dancer
-
Khamisa Wilsher
Barfly Singer
-
Tanya Jade
Barfly Singer
-
Jacqueline Robbins
Bernstein Sister
-
Joyce Robbins
Bernstein Sister
-
Felicia Simone
Backup Singer
- Siera Staples Backup Singer
- Sarah Cantuba New Narrator
