cast
-
John Barnard
Narrator (voice)
- Luke Laterza Self - Police Sergeant (Ret.)
-
J.H. Moncrieff
Self - Crime Writer
-
Damian Turner
Self - Detective (Ret.)
- Dr. Dean Leav Self - Psychologist
- Jared Tepleski Peter / Police Officer / Detective Sumpter / Pastor David Love / Bill McLaughlin
-
Steve Moore
Self - FBI Special Agent (Ret.)
- Todd Picklyck Judge / Sheriff J. Dunning / Investigator / Police Officer
- Corinne Coutts Tracy Fortson / Teresa Stone / Georgia Thompson / Taylor Wright
- Matt Jones Detective Brown / Investigator / Officer Wright / Dale Hausner
- Hank Koreman Emmet County Sheriff Deputy / Todd Chance / Bob the Oil Man / David Weaver
-
Jene Rauch
Self - Ballistics Expert
- Jaamal Sims Nathaniel Schoffer / Johnny Hubbard / Judge Flowers
- Kyle Leensbak Justin Goodwin / Trenton Mallory / Dr. John Pitman
- Alexandra Chubaty Boychuk Jennifer Asbenson / Jessica Chance / Katie
- Chris Sousa Police Officer / Michael Roberts / Officer Levy
- John Mackenzie Eric Naposki / Andrew Urdiales / Officer Laveaux
-
M. William Phelps
Self - Author, 'Beautifully Cruel' / Self - Author, 'Targeted' / Self - Author, 'Deadly Secrets'
- Oleksii Tsybulskyi Jeremy Simko / Detective #1 / Colton Pitonyak
- Adam Walker Officer Laveaux / Police Officer
- Kelvin Henderson Detective / Vince Marinello
- Leonard Romero Self - Ballistics Expert
- Stuart Fenton Self - Prosecutor
- Layne Fingland JD / Detective Fugitt
- Sherri Campbell Ashley McArthur / Elizabeth
- Ron Plenert Ed Fonder / Jack Despain
-
Denesha Lee-Labiuk
Eric's Sister / Janet - Home Health Aide
- Sloane Newton Rhonda Smith / Liz Marinello
- Thomas Beaudry Lyle Kopenkoskey / Detective #1
- Corey Rademaker Deputy Bruscher / Texas Ranger
- Terrence Ferguson Steven, Robin's Dad / Inspector James
- David Sinkarsin Dustin Wehde / David Estrada
- Kylie Friesen Robin / Rhonda Glover
- Dana Mohr Edith / Ruthanne Lodato
- Marlies Marshall Barbara Weaver / Jennifer Cave
- Geoff Girardin Detective Jimenez / Jimmy Joste
- Demetri Bell Youngest Son / Bert Richter
- George Rempel Carl Kopenkoskey / Tess Koster's Husband
- Debra Ross Susan Fassett / Kim Love
- Eldon Wu Joe Kirby / Police Officer
- Roger Bouchard Detective #2 / Fred Andros
- Dakota Rendon Officer Short / Detective
- Evan Connor Brad, Executive Assistant / Police Officer
- Rosemary Poleshuk Jeanmarie Becker / Nanette Johnston
- James Farren Self - District Attorney (Ret.)
- Debbie Darn Jackie, Katie's Mom
- Michael Silk Officer Jones
- Tommy Witherspoon Self - Journalist
- Crawford Long Self - Prosecutor, McClennan County
- Matt Cawthon Self - Texas Ranger (Ret.)
- Jeffrey Foster Keith Gentry
- Christianna Dupas Darlene Gentry
- Jessica Zarrella Self - Prosecutor
- John McCarthy Self - Montgomery County State's Attorney
- Tamika Reid Katrina Ben
- Robert Ochieng Eric Somuah
-
Mike Watkiss
Self - Journalist
-
Camille Kimball
Self - Author, 'A Sudden Shot: The Phoenix Serial Shooter'
- Alex Mutcheson Samuel Dieteman
- A.J. Flick Self - Journalist
- Ben Jimenez Self - Lead Detective
- Kamel Ghoziani Michael Dojaquez
- Warren Bard Eli Curiel
- Holly Dunphy Amber Trudell
- Arwen Smith Amber Trudell
- Jason Simpkins Self - Detective
- Ray Nickle Self - Defense Attorney
- Dan Nel Marc Despain
- Mel Sheikhi Michelle Despain
- Kelly Cassie Detective
- Shaun Edwards Terrance Barker
- Jeffrey Penner Carl Kelley
- Jennifer Mudge Self - Special Prosecutor, State of Illinois
- Mike O'Neill Self - Detective Sergeant, Alton PD (IL)
- Marcya Ervick Bonnie Woodward
- Brent Waters Gary Wilmurth
- Jack Sullivan Detective O'Neill
- Briana Strong Heather Woodward
-
William Whyte
Roger Carroll
- Dianna Raising Monica Carroll
- Nolan Desrochers Nathan Carroll
- Mark Harris Self - Detective (Ret.), Emmet County Sheriff's Office (MI)
- Bryan Klawuhn Self - Attorney
- Lara Wieler Amber Smith
- Maureen Flynn Darlene
- Ward Keith Detective Harris
- J.L. Sumpter Self - Detective (Ret.), Emmet County Sheriff's Office
- Kiersten Dyson Carol Kopenkoskey
- Paul Fleming Self - Defense Attorney
- Alan Gauthreaux Self - Author, Dark Bayou: Infamous Louisiana Homicides
- Tyson Wager Robert, Gun Shop Clerk
- Colin McEvoy Self - Author, 'Love Me or Else'
- David Zellis Self - Former Assistant District Attorney
- Gord Foulkes Pastor Shreaves
- Brittany Isfeld Mary
- Joanne Lussier-Demers Mary-Jane Fonder
- Chad Willhite Self - Sergeant, Pensacola PD (FL)
- Jeff Brown Self - Sergeant, Pensacola PD (FL)
- Danielle Apolinar Self - Journalist
- Andrea Cecchini Cassandra Waller
- Dewi Keogh Zach McArthur
-
Rebecca Morris
Self - Author, 'A Killing in Amish Country'
- Andrew Hyde Self - Defense Attorney
- Oksana Nevoit Barbara Raber
- Jordan Bourquin Eli Weaver
- Diana Fraser Barbara Weaver
- Brennan Easton Weaver's Son
- Callum Anderson Weaver's Son
- Geoff Nevin Detective Luke
- Debbie Dann Female Neighbor
- Rachel Smith Leslie 'Jenea' Chance
- Derek Steele Detective Weaver
- Jeremy Gore Detective Snell
- Jim Caron Todd Chance's Father
- Erica Hastings Carrie Williams
- Tinu Thomas Self - Audio Journalist, 'The Orange Tree' Podcast
- Sam Bassett Self - Defense Attorney - Austin, TX
- Elliott J. Gaillard Colton Pitonyak
- Karen Kempe Sharon Cave
- Kimberley Chartrand DA Stephanie McFarland
- Michael Pope Self - Journalist
- Julien L. Mason Jr. Self - Ballistics Expert
- Doug Edmond Ron Kirby
- Sharon Atkinson Nancy Dunning
- Craig Lawrence Detective
- Cam Gates Charles Severance
- Dana Wright Self - Journalist
- Jordan Bowcutt Randy Stone
- Matt McSherry Detective Rosewaren
- Braden Meilleur Police Officer
- Bohdan Dyck Jason Fassett
- Heather Witherden Dawn Silvernail
- Alison Kolisnyk Dawn Silvernail
- Jeff Whyte Detective Salvatore
- Mike Clarke Jeff Fassett
- Travis Fehr Detective Brown
- Carmine Marceno Self - Sheriff, Lee County (FL)
- David Foraker Self - Sergeant, Lee County Sheriff's Office (FL)
- Deborah Tracy Stark Pamela Hutchinson
- Ardyth Johnson Lois Riess
- Karl Copp Dave Riess
- Lorene Mann-Baxter Tess Koster
- Ben Smith Self - District Attorney, Sac County (IA)
- Oleksandra Pylypenko Tracey Richter
- Neal Domenico DCI Agent Vileta
- James McKay Self - Asst State's Attorney, Cook County (IL)
- Kierra Thompson Robbin Brandley
- Jill Livingston Cassandra Corum
- Ron Bamieh Self - Defense Attorney (CA)
- Rodney Huculak Dave Laut
- Lori Macario Jane Laut
- Alexander Slobidker Detective
- Ben Williams Self - Special Agent (Ret.), GBI
- Ryan Jensen Doug Benton
- Cary Tardi Larry Bridges
- Bob Unger Sheriff
- Burl Barer Self - Author, 'Fatal Beauty'
- Rick Maiers Sammy
- Bob Kish Self - Sheriff (Ret.), Vermillion, OH
- Sheryl Monaghan Julene Simko
- Stéphane Normandeau Officer Reinheimer
- Jason Soltys Lead Investigator
- Lonnie Farr Roger Perry
- Larry Montgomery Self - Investigator (Ret.], Orange County DA's Office (CA)
- Matt Murphy Self - District Attorney (Ret.), Orange County (CA)
