cast
-
Renée Zellweger
Pam Hupp
-
Josh Duhamel
Joel Schwartz
-
Judy Greer
Leah Askey
-
Gideon Adlon
Mariah Day
-
Sean Bridgers
Mark Hupp
-
Suanne Spoke
Janet
-
Mac Brandt
Detective Ryan McCarrick
-
Katy Mixon
Betsy Faria
-
Glenn Fleshler
Russ Faria
-
Keith Morrison
Narrator (voice)
-
Olivia Luccardi
Lily Day
-
Ben Chase
Nate Swanson
-
Drew Scheid
Travis Hupp
-
Rachael Thompson
Tina
-
Jesse Scott Egan
Detective Merkel
-
Lara Grice
Cousin Mary
-
Ann Mahoney
Tammy
-
Sarah Stipe
Sarah Hupp / Sarah Hupp (uncredited)
-
Susan Shalhoub Larkin
Luci
-
Alice Barrett
Cathy Singer
- Michael Hinson Channel 2 Reporter
-
Patricia French
Minnie
-
Dane Davenport
Mike Wood
-
Jeff Robins
Juror #2
-
Adam David Thompson
Captain Mike Lang
-
Catherine Carlen
Bonnie
- Jeff Ryan Baker Louis Gumpenberger
-
Barry Clifton
Jerry
-
Ricky Catter
Gus
-
Heather Magee
Judge Mennemeyer
-
D.A. Obahor
Sean Walker
- William McGovern Jim
-
Morgan Roberts
Evan
-
Anthony Michael Frederick
Firefighter
-
Cindy Pol
Whitney
-
Clayton Eustis
Young Sarah / Sarah at 11 Years Old
-
Rob Steinberg
Michael J. Kruse
-
John C. Klein
Bailiff
-
Billy Slaughter
Scott
-
Alec Zais
Young Mark Hupp
-
Lena Clark
Lisa
-
Celia Weston
Shirley Neumann
-
Samantha Beaulieu
Friendly Nurse
-
Tracy Brotherton
News Reporter
-
Merah Benoit
Leah Askey's Daughter
-
Michael Krikorian
Greg Chatton
-
Michael Carollo
Officer Divozzo
- Victoria Harris CSI Tech
-
Jordan Mann
Officer Rose
-
Mike Harkins
O'Fallon Office Dave
- Jasmine Martin Darla
-
Randall D. Cunningham
Polygrapher
-
Gralen Bryant Banks
Plastic Surgeon
-
Chad Governale
Courtroom Bailiff
-
David Kors
Juror #3
- Ron Centanni Russ' Family Member
-
Didi Costine
Teenage Witch
- Harper Herrin Sarah at 6 Years Old
-
Kyler Porche
Randy Gunderson
-
Emily Topper
Young Pam Hupp
- Skip Bolen News Photographer (uncredited)
-
Lorna Street Dopson
Zumba Instructor
-
Kenny Alfonso
Bob Rivers
-
Jackson Kelly
Big Shot Manager
- Carl A. Chauvin Attorney (uncredited)
- Liz Reinhardt Delsa Reporter #1
-
Cuyle Carvin
Btian Hilke
-
Jeremy Dean
Officer Carrigan
-
Wendy Conrad
Inmate
-
Bill Martin Williams
Judge Ted House
-
Suzette Lange
Prisoner
-
Kurt McKinney
Judge Cunningham
-
Jessie Terrebonne
O'Fallon County Operator
-
Jay Pennington
Bradford Kessler
-
Terese Aiello
911 Operator
- Jordan V. Allen CSI Tech
- Anne Speed Bar Patron (uncredited)
-
Douglas M. Griffin
Judge Ohmer
- Madeline Colombo Bubbly Acolyte
- René J.F. Piazza Auctioneer #1
-
Ian Hoch
Cybercrimes Expert
- Nicole Francis Miller Teen Pet Shop Employee
-
Rachel G. Whittle
Realtor Sally
-
Kerry Cahill
Carol Alford
-
Becki Davis
Louis' Mom
-
Luke Sexton
PV Fake Louis
- Jason T. Olivier Courtroom - family friend (uncredited)
